Built to Last: Lamplighter Brewing’s Move to Employee Ownership

We, at Walden, are nerds about governance structures. Appreciating the finer points of our mutualist structure involves discussions of voting rights, equity distribution, and “corporators” (whatever or whoever those are!). Those discussions are more likely to put someone to sleep than get them excited. But those technicalities amount to something significant: How does a founder design something to live beyond their tenure, and preserve its original intent against incentives that pull towards short-term profit and unbridled growth?

Many of today’s large corporate brands are products of those incentives. Maybe they start small, with a theory of how they’d be different, then take outside capital to grow. Investors require returns, concessions get made in the name of efficiency and wider margins, and eventually an outside observer might look at that larger company and not recognize it.

AC Jones and Cayla Marvil moved to Cambridge in 2013 after graduating from Middlebury College. They were avid home brewers and beer lovers, and were surprised to find that Cambridge didn’t have more breweries — and so their entrepreneurial journey began. Lamplighter Brewing Co. opened in 2016, and their goal was building a better kind of bar and restaurant — for both employees and patrons. In Cayla’s words: “I had been in some toxic and abusive workplaces and was disgruntled that this was the norm in hospitality. I saw Lamplighter as an opportunity to build a company with a culture I was proud of and a safe and supportive space for everybody.”

It grew quickly, winning Taproom of the Year in 2017, opening a second location in 2018, and launching their own coffee brand/café in 2019. Cayla and AC were named to Forbes’ 30 Under 30 list for food & drink. But they were only 23 years old when the taproom opened, and had not envisioned their entire professional lives being defined by a singular project, even one as rewarding as Lamplighter. AC started a graduate program in engineering at MIT in 2022, and Cayla was a 2024 graduate of Stanford’s Graduate School of Business. As their curiosities led them elsewhere, what should become of their baby?

A sale to investors or other outside owners seemed sure to compromise their values — and the things that made Lamplighter special in the first place. Continuing to own it but watching from afar (and profiting along the way) felt disingenuous. In conversation with Dan Kenary, the founder of Harpoon Brewery (which transitioned to employee ownership via an Employee Stock Ownership Plan — or ESOP — in 2014), they discovered a third way.

An Employee Ownership Trust (EOT) is popular in the United Kingdom, but relatively novel in the US. While ESOPs are costly to set up and maintain ($100K+) and fit poorly in hospitality (where many employees stay for relatively short amounts of time), EOTs offer flexibility. They’re cheaper to establish, and ownership in an EOT is transferred to a trust that operates for the benefit of employees. Profits are paid out as a profit share (which conveys benefits to short-term employees as well as those who stick around longer), and an employee stewardship committee performs critical governance functions.  

In collaboration with Common Trust, Lamplighter finalized their transition to the EOT structure in October. The employee trust purchasesd the business from its original owners (in this case, Cayla, AC, and other original investors) with cash secured from a loan, and future profits fund loan repayment. Cayla talked to a range of local banks to evaluate their fit. There was plenty of enthusiasm, but none that provided the mission alignment and holistic partnership on offer at Walden.

Cayla and AC continue to stay involved in the brewery, but it now has its own stewards: its employees. The model incentivizes employees to participate in the evolution of the business, preserving essential elements of its DNA while making it their own. Employees have been receptive, even as they navigate a learning curve. Dan Hannegin, a brewer, says, “It seems like a really cool chance to technically be a brewery owner.”

‍

Member FDIC.